Thirteen challenges to the record, none of which changes who did it. One measurement, the cooling rate, stays open until the ED flowsheet surfaces. The one datum at the edge of physiology, the 82.1 °F core temperature, adds up in the wrong direction for the challenge: a colder body means an earlier jump, while Patrick was on surveillance video. The criminal-responsibility question that hung the jury is real, and it is not a challenge to who did it.
Short answers first. Each one links to the full entry below with the evidence, the expert testimony and the science.
Lindsay Clancy strangled Cora (5), Dawson (3) and Callan (8 mo) with exercise bands in the basement of the family's Duxbury home on 24 January 2023, then cut her wrists and neck and went out a second-story window. The act is admitted by her, by her counsel in opening, and contested by no party. The only litigated question was criminal responsibility.
Every point below is fixed by surveillance video, a business employee, carrier records or a device extraction entered at trial. Click a marker. The shaded red span is the only window in which Patrick's whereabouts rest on his own account: from leaving ThreeV to the 911 call, including the drive home.
Timestamps above come from press reports and AI-assisted recaps of testimony. Official transcripts for Days 8 and 14 would confirm them and are on the document list.
Each challenge runs the site's eight steps: origin, the challenge stated fairly, evidence for it, the record against it, experts both ways, science both ways, a grade of the record, and the document that would change it. Where a step comes up empty the entry says "none". Filter by the kind of evidence a challenge leans on.
The record adds up. The strongest single artifact the challenges have is the 82.1 °F reading, and its correct implication is that Lindsay went out the window earlier rather than later, during the interval Patrick is on video, a ~17-minute drive away.
Every other component either misreads a technical detail (watch sampling, latent prints, DNA mixtures, pill crushing), inverts an inference (the lawyer question, the proxy change), or is factually false (high-school sweetheart, marathon, Costa Rica, secret child). The theory requires the timeline, two businesses, carrier records, Apple device logs, crime-scene DNA, the fall injuries and every one of Lindsay's accounts from January 2023 to June 2026 to be fabricated, misread, incomplete, or contradicted, and offers nothing that survives the 5:34 call.
Commentary. The movement's function, as Morrissey, Coduto and Wagner each note from different angles, is to let people extend compassion to Lindsay without accepting that a devoted mother can kill her children while ill. That is a psychological need, not an evidentiary finding.
This is step eight of the method applied to the whole entry. Anyone holding one of these can overturn a section; nobody holding a vibe can.
READ marks a page read in full; EXCERPT marks a page used via search excerpt only, including sites that blocked automated retrieval (CNN, CBC, NewsNation). All links are live.
Every revision to this entry is logged here with a date. A grade changes when one of the documents listed above surfaces.